digitalmars.D.learn - Why isn't this expression const?

Brian Palmer (7/7) May 09 2007 This code won't compile:

Silverling (5/16) May 09 2007 Try

Frits van Bommel (3/21) May 09 2007 It's not an array. Look at the first line of his code: it's a struct.

Brian Palmer (6/20) May 09 2007 Sorry, now that I read what I wrote I wasn't clear. I didn't mean changi...

Daniel Keep (19/42) May 09 2007 Look at the error you got: the compiler is converting ROT_FORCE_CCW.y

Don Clugston (3/14) May 09 2007 It's just lack of compiler smarts. Originally, hardly any constant
Stewart Gordon (6/12) May 11 2007
Brian Palmer (2/19) May 11 2007 That clears things up. Thanks all for the great answers, I'll just work ...

Brian Palmer <d brian.codekitchen.net> writes:

This code won't compile:

 struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};

That last line gives me the error:

 Error: non-constant expression *((& ROT_FORCE_CCW+4)) * -1.0e+0F

Strangely, I can do the equivalent three lines with basic types like ints just
fine, but I can't get this struct initialization to work. Am I doing something
wrong, or is it just lack of compiler smarts? I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd
1.007)

May 09 2007

Silverling <este_aqui_ hotmail.com.remove.underscores> writes:

Brian Palmer Wrote:

 This code won't compile:
 
  struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};
 
 That last line gives me the error:
 
  Error: non-constant expression *((& ROT_FORCE_CCW+4)) * -1.0e+0F
 
 Strangely, I can do the equivalent three lines with basic types like ints just
fine, but I can't get this struct initialization to work. Am I doing something
wrong, or is it just lack of compiler smarts? I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd
1.007)

Try
const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = [0, 400_000, 0];
const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = [0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0];

That's how you init an array. I assume that Vector3 is an alias for float[3].

May 09 2007

Frits van Bommel <fvbommel REMwOVExCAPSs.nl> writes:

Silverling wrote:
 Brian Palmer Wrote:
 
 This code won't compile:

  struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};

 That last line gives me the error:

  Error: non-constant expression *((& ROT_FORCE_CCW+4)) * -1.0e+0F

 Strangely, I can do the equivalent three lines with basic types like ints just
fine, but I can't get this struct initialization to work. Am I doing something
wrong, or is it just lack of compiler smarts? I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd
1.007)


I can't get it to compile for ints either...

 Try
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = [0, 400_000, 0];
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = [0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0];
 
 That's how you init an array. I assume that Vector3 is an alias for float[3].

It's not an array. Look at the first line of his code: it's a struct.

May 09 2007

Brian Palmer <d brian.codekitchen.net> writes:

Frits van Bommel Wrote:

 Silverling wrote:
 Brian Palmer Wrote:
 
 ...


 
 I can't get it to compile for ints either...

Sorry, now that I read what I wrote I wasn't clear. I didn't mean changing
float to int, I meant doing:

 const int a = 5;
 const int b = a*-1;

works as expected.

 
 Try
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = [0, 400_000, 0];
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = [0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0];
 
 That's how you init an array. I assume that Vector3 is an alias for float[3].

 
 It's not an array. Look at the first line of his code: it's a struct.

Yes, thanks.

May 09 2007

Daniel Keep <daniel.keep.lists gmail.com> writes:

Brian Palmer wrote:
 Frits van Bommel Wrote:
 
 Silverling wrote:
 Brian Palmer Wrote:

 ...


 I can't get it to compile for ints either...

 
 Sorry, now that I read what I wrote I wasn't clear. I didn't mean changing
float to int, I meant doing:
 
  const int a = 5;
  const int b = a*-1;
 
 works as expected.
 
 Try
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = [0, 400_000, 0];
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = [0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0];

 That's how you init an array. I assume that Vector3 is an alias for float[3].

 It's not an array. Look at the first line of his code: it's a struct.

 
 Yes, thanks.

Look at the error you got: the compiler is converting ROT_FORCE_CCW.y
into *(&ROT_FORCE_CCW + 4), and since pointers can't be used at
compile-time, the evaluation fails.

A workaround might be to store 400_000 in a named constant, and use that
instead.

const ROT_FORCE = 400_000.;
const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, ROT_FORCE, 0};
const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, -ROT_FORCE, 0};

	-- Daniel

-- 
int getRandomNumber()
{
    return 4; // chosen by fair dice roll.
              // guaranteed to be random.
}

http://xkcd.com/

v2sw5+8Yhw5ln4+5pr6OFPma8u6+7Lw4Tm6+7l6+7D
i28a2Xs3MSr2e4/6+7t4TNSMb6HTOp5en5g6RAHCP  http://hackerkey.com/

May 09 2007

Don Clugston <dac nospam.com.au> writes:

Brian Palmer wrote:
 This code won't compile:
 
  struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
  const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};
 
 That last line gives me the error:
 
  Error: non-constant expression *((& ROT_FORCE_CCW+4)) * -1.0e+0F
 
 Strangely, I can do the equivalent three lines with basic types like ints just
fine, but I can't get this struct initialization to work. Am I doing something
wrong, or is it just lack of compiler smarts? I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd
1.007)

It's just lack of compiler smarts. Originally, hardly any constant 
folding worked.

May 09 2007

"Stewart Gordon" <smjg_1998 yahoo.com> writes:

"Brian Palmer" <d brian.codekitchen.net> wrote in message 
news:f1t6en$t32$1 digitalmars.com...
 This code won't compile:

 struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};

<snip>
 Am I doing something wrong, or is it just lack of compiler
 smarts?  I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd 1.007)

It's the compiler getting confused.

http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=609

Stewart.

May 11 2007

Brian Palmer <d brian.codekitchen.net> writes:

Stewart Gordon Wrote:

 "Brian Palmer" <d brian.codekitchen.net> wrote in message 
 news:f1t6en$t32$1 digitalmars.com...
 This code won't compile:

 struct Vector3 { float x,y,z; }
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CCW = {0, 400_000, 0};
 const Vector3 ROT_FORCE_CW  = {0, ROT_FORCE_CCW.y*-1, 0};

 <snip>
 Am I doing something wrong, or is it just lack of compiler
 smarts?  I'm using (gdc 0.23, using dmd 1.007)

 
 It's the compiler getting confused.
 
 http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=609
 
 Stewart. 
 

That clears things up. Thanks all for the great answers, I'll just work around
it for now.

May 11 2007

D Programming

C/C++ Programming

Other

digitalmars.D.learn - Why isn't this expression const?