digitalmars.D - Alias parameters for templates does not accept built-in types
- Deokjae Lee (18/18) Aug 13 2010 import std.stdio;
- Michal Minich (12/19) Aug 14 2010 I would guess that it is because name of built-in types are keywords,
import std.stdio; template T(alias X) { } void main() { writeln(typeid(typeof(T!int))); } dmd 2.048 on linux produces an error for the above code. Error: template instance T!(int) does not match template declaration T (alias X) Built-in primitive types cannot be used as template alias parameters. User-defined types like structs or classes work well. I think this is a bug and reported it. http://d.puremagic.com/issues/show_bug.cgi?id=4639 However, I got a reply that the behaviour is intended. I think the limitation that the built-in types are not accepted as alias parameters for templates is not beautiful :( That's a kind of lack of symmetry and practice :) I'd like to know the reason of such a limitation.
Aug 13 2010
On Sat, 14 Aug 2010 04:03:15 +0000, Deokjae Lee wrote:template T(alias X) {Error: template instance T!(int) does not match template declaration T (alias X)However, I got a reply that the behavior is intended. I think the limitation that the built-in types are not accepted as alias parameters for templates is not beautiful :( That's a kind of lack of symmetry and practice :) I'd like to know the reason of such a limitation.I would guess that it is because name of built-in types are keywords, while other names are not. But it is possible to overload templates with and without alias: template T(alias X) { pragma(msg, "alias X ->"~ X.stringof); } template T(X) { pragma(msg, "X ->" ~ X.stringof); } ...given the ability to send keyword aliases to template, templates would come closer to macros.
Aug 14 2010